COMPARATIVE CHANGE IN THE LEGAL STATUS OF TRANSGENDER PERSONS

Zorica Mršević

DOI Number
-
First page
115
Last page
132

Abstract


The experiences of countries all around the world show that there is no single, the same and universally applicable scenario of legal changes in terms of regulating the status of transgender people. The process most commonly begins by providing gender reassignment hormonal surgery procedures, which are followed by the legal recognition of a new gender identity. The next step necessarily implies the need to enact legislation to regulate the so-called social gender or gender identity, according to the right to self-determination of transgender persons, which is unrelated to previously undertaken medical treatment and gender reassignment surgery. Some countries have gone far in the implementation of this third step, while others have not taken even the first steps. Notably, different initiatives and events may be observed worldwide, many of which constitute the necessary "first steps" aimed at increasing the social acceptance of gender diversity. These steps may seem small and insufficient, but they are actually huge and significant in breaking the sanctity of the binary gender division and accepting specific transgender individuals. All the steps are based on the need to protect all people, including transgender people, from discrimination, violence, different forms of victimization, and other impacts of neglecting gender identity. Once gender identity becomes legally protected, it is possible to gradually build procedures and other types of legal protection mechanisms designed for all people whose gender identity differs from the rigid binary division into women and men, as the only identity options. In Serbia, there is still a significant lack of legal regulations on the status of transgender persons, which implies that there is much room for improvement in this area. While it would be easy to keep ignoring this issue, it would be irresponsible to exclude transgender persons from the analysis of social phenomena involving marginalization and victimization.

Keywords

transgender, gender identity, gender mark change in identification documents, first steps

Full Text:

PDF

References


Applying for Gender Recognition Certificate,

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/7/section/1

Appyling for Gender Recognition Certificate,

http://www.justice.gov.uk/downloads/tribunals/gender-recognition-panel/list-of-approved-countries-or-territories/table-approved-countries.pdf.

Barron, A. (2015). Boys wear skirts to school in Mexico City to challenge gender roles, Flama, http://www.theflama.com/boys-wear-skirts-challenge-gender-roles-mexico-city-school-1475922250.html. 25 November 2015.

BETA/AFP nedelja, 20. decembar 2015, Prvi transrodni sudija izabran u Kanadi,

[First transgender judge elected in Canada], B92, http://www.b92.net/info/vesti/index.php?yyyy=2015&mm=12& dd=20&nav_category=78&nav_id=1076796

Bolivija: Istorijska pobeda za trans osobe [Bolivia: A historic victory for transgender persons] http://transserbia.org/vesti/994-bolivija-istorijska-pobeda-za-trans-osobe.

Damien, W. R, von Doussab, R, Powerc, J. (2015). The family and romantic relationships of trans and gender diverse. Australians: an exploratory survey. Sexual and Relationship Therapy, Vol. 30, No. 2, pp. 243-255, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14681994.2014.992409.

Danska prva evropska zemlja koja omogućuje pravnu promenu oznake roda bez kliničke dijagnoze, [Danmark: the first European country to legally recognize a change of gender mark without clinical diagnosis], http://transserbia.org/vesti/664-danska-je-postala-prva-evropska-zemlja-koja-omogucuje-pravnu-promenu-oznake-roda-bez-klinicke-dijagnoze.

Duffy Nick, 2015, Boys can now wear skirts to school in Puerto Rico, Pink News. 12. October, http://www.pinknews.co.uk/2015/10/12/boys-can-now-wear-skirts-to-school-in-puerto-rico/.

Editor: huaxia, 2015, Hundreds of Vietnamese transgender people request new identification, English.news.cn, 12. August, http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2015-08/12/c_134509278.htm.

Editor: huaxia, 2015, Hundreds of Vietnamese transgender people request new identification, English.news.cn, 12. August.http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2015-08/12/c_134509278.htm.

Ellis, J. S, McNeil, J, Bailey, L. (2014). Gender, stage of transition and situational avoidance: a UK study of trans people's experiences, Sexual and Relationship, Therapy, 29:3, pp. 351-364. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/14681994.2014.902925.

Equal protection: Repeal surgery requirement for gender change on birth certificate (HB 2093), http://aclu-or.org/Repeal-surgery-requirement-gender-change-birth-certificate-HB_2093.

Evropa ukida zakon o prisilnoj sterilizaciji trans osoba [Europe abolishes the law on forced sterilisation of transgender persons], http://transserbia.org/vesti/824-evropa-ukida-zakon-o-prisilnoj-sterilizaciji-trans-osoba.

Geen, R. E., (2010), Shifting Paradigms: Moving Beyond “Trans101” In: Sexuality Education, American Journal of Sexuality Education, 5: pp.1–16.

Gender Recognition Act, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/7/pdfs/ukpga_20040007_en.pdf

Hawaii bill for birth certificate gender change passes, http://honolulu.suntimes.com/hnl-politics-government/7/100/78796/hawaii-bill-birth-certificate-gender-change.

Hirurški zahvati i sterilizacija izbrisani iz revolucionarnog LGBTI zakona [Surgery and sterilisation repealed form the revolutionary LGBT Act], http://transserbia.org/vesti/839-malta-hirurski-zahvati-i-sterilizacija-izbrisani-iz-revolucionarnog-lgbti-zakona.

Hrvatska: Transeksualci će i pre operacije u dokumentima moći promeniti pol [Croatia: Transsexual persons may change gender in identification documents even before surgery], http://transserbia.org/vesti/246-hrvatska-transeksualci-ce-i-pre-operacije-moci-u-dokumentima-promeniti-pol-246.

Istorijska rezolucija o pravima trans osoba [A historical Resolution on trans persons’ rights] http://transserbia.org/vesti/856-istorijska-rezolucija-o-pravima-trans-osoba.

Izrael: Trans osobama se dozvoljava zakonska promena roda bez operacije [Israel: Trans persons allowed to change gender status without surgery], http://transserbia.org/vesti/790-izrael-trans-osobama-se-dozvoljava-zakonska-promena-roda-bez-operacije.

Kolumbija: Dozvoljava se promena roda, bez operacija [Columbia: Gender change allowed without surgery], http://www.transserbia.org/vesti/891-kolumbija-dozvoljava-se-promena-roda-bez-operacija.

Mršević, Z. (2011). Kriminalci ili žrtve kriminalaca – transseksualne osobe [Transgender persons: Criminal offenders or Victims], Revija za kriminologiju i krivično pravo, vol. 49, 2/3, pp. 341-356, http://zoricamrsevic.in.rs/najnovije/KriminalciIliZrtveMrsevic.pdf

Mršević, Z. (2011). Promena pola iz medicinskih razloga [Gender change for medical reasons), Lilić, S. (ed). In: Perspektive implementacije evropskih standarda u pravni sistem Srbije, pp. 271 – 283. Pravni fakultet Univerzitet u Beogradu. http://zoricamrsevic.in.rs/najnovije/Promena_pola.pdf.

Mršević, Z. (2012). Pravni i politički aspekti transseksualnosti [Legal and political aspects of Transsexuality], Pravo i politika, vol V, 1: pp. 64-81.Novi Sad: Fakultet za evropske pravno političke studije, Novi Sad http://zoricamrsevic.in.rs/najnovije/Pravo_i_politika-2012.pdf.

Mršević, Z, (2013). Transseksualne osobe i porodica - između diskriminacije i inkluzije [Transsexual persons and the family unit: between discrimination and inclusion], Temida, vol 16, 2, pp. 57-73. http://zoricamrsevic.in.rs/najnovije/201306-Transseksualne_osobe_porodica-Mrsevic.pdf.

Nema roda [No gender], http://transserbia.org/vesti/531-nema-roda.

Portugal adopts Trans Law, http://tgeu.org/portugal-adopts-trans-law-8-days-for-legal-gender-recognition/; Applying for a passport-Additional information for transgender and transsexual customers,https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/251703/Applying_for_a_passport_additional_information.PDF.

Press Releases, Polish Parliament makes trans history http://transfuzja.org/en/artykuly/press_releases/polish_parliament_makes_trans_history.htm.

Rhode island drops surgery requirement for ransgender birthcertificate changes http://www.lgbtqnation.com/2014/10/rhode-island-drops-surgery-requirement-for-transgender-birthcertificate-changes/

The narratives of transgender rights mobilization in Spain, http://www.academia.edu/1377556/the_narratives_of_transgender_rights_mobilization_in_Spain.

Trans Hawaiians Will No Longer Need to “Prove” Their Surgeries to Change Their Birth Certificate, http://www.advocate.com/politics/transgender/2015/05/06/trans-hawaiians-will-no-longer-need-prove-their-surgeries-change-bir.

Transgender Bolivians Gain Right to Change Gender on ID Cards http://www.telesurtv.net/english/news/Transgender-Bolivians-Gain-Right-to-Change-Gender-on-ID-Cards-20151126-0040.html.

Transgender Canadians can now self-identify on citizenship documents without sex–reassignment surgery, http://news.nationalpost.com/news/canada/federal-government-quietly-eases-requirements-for-canadians-seeking-to-change-gender-on-citizen-certificate.

Transgender people born in Ontario can change birth-certificate gender without surgery, Province says,http://news.nationalpost.com/news/canada/transgender-people-in-ontario-can-change-birth-certificate-gender-without-surgery-province-says.

Transgender rights victory in Vermont, http://www.thetaskforce.org/transgender-rights-victory-in-vermont/ .

Ustavni sud Hrvatske: “Žena može biti muškarac i bez promjene spola” [The Constitutional Court of Croatia: “A woman may be a man even without a sex-change operation], http://transserbia.org/vesti/619-ustavni-sud-hrvatske-zena-moze-biti-muskarac-i-bez-promjene-spola.

Vijetnam: donet zakon koji štiti prava transrodnih osoba [Vietnam: a law to protect transgender rights], http://transserbia.org/vesti/993-vijetnam-donet-zakon-koji-stiti-prava-transrodnih-osoba.

Williams, J. (2015). School celebrates annual ‘skirt day’ to promote gender diversity, Pink News, 23rd November, 2015, http://www.pinknews.co.uk/2015/11/23/school-celebrates-annual-skirt-day-to-promote-gender-diversity-photos/.

Xinhua, 2015, Gender reassignment, transgender people recognized in Vietnam, English.news.cn, 24 November 2015, http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2015-11/24/c_134850153.htm.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


ISSN 1450-5517 (Print)
ISSN 2406-1786 (Online)